Illinois inmate Timothy Krajcir confesses to 5 unsolved Cape murders

~ Click here for full coverage of this story, including photos, video, and background documents

Brenda and Mary Parsh. Sheila Cole. Margie Call. Mildred Wallace.

Timothy W. Krajcir has confessed to all of them.

Krajcir pleaded guilty this morning to the 1982 rape and murder of Deborah Sheppard, a Southern Illinois University-Carbondale student. It was a crime that had gone unsolved for over two decades. With his admission of guilt in the Sheppard killing, police prepare to close the books on five other unsolved murders here in Cape Girardeau.

For the past two decades, the unresolved killings haunted the town as detectives worked endless hours, trying to piece together the evidence and answer the questions that plagued law enforcement, family members and residents.

"I cannot think of anything we failed to do," said Lt. John Brown, now a campus police officer at Southeast Missouri State University, who had been lead detective on the homicides.

At one point, police even had a witness, who believed he had seen Cole's car cross the bridge into Illinois, hypnotized to see how much detail they could recall, Brown said.

In 2003, some semen samples found at the scenes of the Call and Wallace murders were tested by the Missouri State Highway Patrol crime lab, and failed to pinpoint a suspect because there was not enough usable genetic material to get a DNA profile.

At that time, Cape Girardeau detective Tracy Lemonds said a confession to the killings may be the last hope, the Southeast Missourian reported.

This past summer, Cape Girardeau police detective Jim Smith took over investigating the unsolved homicides full time.

Then, this November, at Big Muddy River Correctional Center in Ina, Il., where Krajcir has been incarcerated for the last 10 years, the suspect provided Smith with details only the killer would know as he described raping Brenda Parsh, Cole, Call, and Wallace.

Police refused to elaborate on what it was Krajcir said that convinced them they had finally caught the killer.

After DNA evidence tied Krajcir to the Sheppard murder, Smith realized the killing occurred between the murders of Call, on Jan. 27, and Wallace, on June 21, 1982. He contacted the Carbondale police department to inquire about whether Krajcir could have visited Cape Girardeau during those months.

At first, it seemed like another dead end.

"At that point, nothing linked Krajcir to anything in Missouri," said Lt. Paul Echols of the Carbondale police department.

Most of the details of the Sheppard murder did not match up with the way the other women had been killed, leaving police little to go on in tying Krajcir to the unsolved homicides, Echols said.

After DNA proved with a one-in-a-980 billion match that Krajcir killed Sheppard, Carbondale police continued to gather evidence against him - and that's when law enforcement began to suspect he may have committed some crimes outside of Carbodale, Echols said.

Based on the way Sheppard was murdered, Echols developed a profile of the way Krajcir killed, and submitted it to surrounding law enforcement agencies.

Then, Cape Girardeau detective Tracy Lemonds compared the profile to an unsolved rape dating back to 1982. The details were identical to the rape of Sheppard.

"That's when we knew we were onto something," Echols said.

Now, police had something solid to go on: a strong suspect they could place in Cape Girardeau around the time of the string of killings, police chief Carl Kinnison said.

A DNA sample was obtained from the Wallace crime scene and preserved. Lemonds was an evidence technician at the time and distinctly remembers collecting the sample.

Smith was sitting at his desk at the Cape Girardeau police department when he got the call from the crime lab in Jefferson City: They had a match.

"It brought tears to my eyes," Smith said.

Kinnison described the analysis as a "cannot exclude match." According to Echols, that's about a one-in-720,000 match.

A few weeks later, Lemonds received a call from a former evidence technician with whom he had worked the Call and Wallace crime scenes and now is a crime analyst with the Southeast Missouri Crime lab.

He wanted Lemonds to look at a palm print that had been lifted from the Wallace's home, and compared to one taken from Krajcir.

That was the moment when Lemonds said he knew they had found their killer.

Smith immediately arranged to interview Krajcir.

The 63-year-old former ambulance driver politely denied everything, said Smith.

He said he had never met Wallace, broke into her house or waited for her to get home, Kinnison said.

"The next best thing to a confession is a provable lie," said prosecuting attorney Morley Swingle.

The palm print and DNA evidence tied him to the Wallace killing, and Swingle intended to see the death penalty in the case, he said.

Then Krajcir mentioned he would be willing to listen to what police had to say about the other killings in the area if he knew death penalty was off the table.

"He said, 'I have nothing to live for, I'll be in prison for the rest of my life, but I don't have a death wish either,'" said Smith.

Swingle said he was set against the idea of agreeing to the arrangement, even to learn new information about the other murders, until he met with the surviving family members of the victims.

"They all agreed they'd rather find out the truth about what happened than seek the death penalty and have him take it to his grave," said Swingle.

He sent a letter to the prison, explaining that he would not seek the death penalty for the rape and murder of Wallace if Krajcir could provide accurate and detailed information leading to the resolution of the other unsolved murders.

Aware of the danger that Krajcir may falsely confess to the other murders simply to avoid the death penalty, Swingle said he insisted that Krajcir be able to provide information he could not have possibly learned from another source.

He did not seem to show much remorse, Smith said.

Krajcir admitted to raping Brenda Parsh, Cole, Call, and Wallace, but a legal technicality will bar rape charges from being filed in the Parsh and Cole homicides, because the statute of limitations has run out, Swingle said.

According to a Nov. 21, 1977 Southeast Missourian article, autopsy reports said Cole had not been sexually assaulted.

There is no statute of limitations on any class A felony in Missouri, but it wasn't until 1980 that rape became a class A felony, so Krajcir cannot be charged for the 1977 rapes, Swingle said.

Brown said he was thrilled to learn about the arrest, although it seemed odd to think that if the case went to trial, he would have nothing to testify about, despite the investigation having occupied a constant presence in his mind since he was assigned the Parsh homicide in 1977.

"As I entered the pearly gates, I was going to ask St. Peter who did those killings," he said.