Judge allows Chicago suit against Jussie Smollett to proceed

CHICAGO -- A federal judge Tuesday refused to dismiss Chicago's lawsuit against former "Empire" actor Jussie Smollett.

U.S. District Virginia Kendall's ruling means Chicago's suit seeking to recoup $130,000 city officials say the police department spent investigating Smollett's claim he was a victim of a racist and homophobic attack in January can proceed.

The motion by Smollett's attorneys was a longshot because their argument boiled down to the contention Smollett shouldn't be required to reimburse the police department because he couldn't have known how much time and money would be spent investigating his allegations.

The police conducted an exhaustive investigation including nearly 1,900 hours of overtime as they looked into Smollett's claim he was beaten by two masked men on a downtown Chicago street in January and they used racist and homophobic slurs and looped a noose around his neck before fleeing.

For days, detectives scoured the neighborhood for witnesses, analyzed dozens of videos from surveillance cameras on the street, on buildings and inside taxi cabs, and interviewed store owners in search of who might have sold the suspects the rope.

When Police Superintendent Eddie Johnson announced charges against Smollett, he angrily made clear the stakes of the investigation and why it was so important police solve the case, saying Smollett "took advantage of the pain and anger of racism to promote his career."

In March, Cook County State's Attorney Kim Foxx's office announced a stunning decision to drop the 16 felony counts related to making a false report, which angered Johnson and then-Mayor Rahm Emanuel and led to the city's lawsuit against Smollett and to a county judge's decision to appoint a special prosecutor to examine the way Foxx's office handled the investigation.

Although Smollett has maintained his innocence, the police department is adamant there is a mountain of evidence that shows Smollett staged the attack with two brothers he knew. And with the appointment of the special prosecutor, there remains the possibility that Smollett could be charged again with staging the attack.