The sitting and the waiting. That was the most difficult part for recently graduated high school athletes Tyler Slinkard and Trevor Morehead.
They don't have much in common at first glance -- Slinkard's a baseball player from Jackson and Morehead's a three-sport athlete in football, basketball and track and field for Chaffee -- but they both learned what it was like to be on the sidelines watching their teammates prepare and compete without them over the last year before working their way back onto the field.
Now they are both finalists to be the Semoball Awards Comeback Player of the Year along with Jackson wrestler Jarrett Reisenbichler, Perryville volleyball player Libbi Schnurbusch and Twin Rivers basketball and baseball player Nathan Watson.
Slinkard and Morehead were on hand for the formal announcement of the finalists in front of dozens of fans Saturday morning at a selection show hosted by First Midwest Bank in Cape Girardeau and broadcast live on SEMO ESPN radio. The finalists for baseball, softball, boys track and field, girls track and field, girls soccer, golf and boys tennis player of the year were also revealed as well as for coach of the year and the sportsmanship award.
The Semoball Awards, presented by Southeast Health and featuring Olympic champion Jennie Finch as the keynote speaker, will be held July 11 at the Southeast Missouri State River Campus in Cape Girardeau.
"It was very emotional," Morehead said about watching his team compete after tearing his ACL in Chaffee's fourth football game of the season. "It was a very emotional process. There was more than one game where I was just sitting there on the sidelines on my crutches with tears in my eyes. Especially after you go from such a successful season we had last year, and honestly it was just like a nightmare. I kept waiting to wake up for it to not be. You just have to keep pushing forward. Life's not a fairytale."
After missing the remainder of the football season and the entire basketball season, Morehead returned to earn all-state honors in the shot put at the Class 2 track and field championships.
Slinkard had part of a finger on his pitching hand cut off in a weight-lifting accident in January before returning to appear in 21 games for the Indians in the spring. He hit .286 for a Jackson team that advanced to the Class 5 quarterfinals for just the second time in program history and had a 2.95 ERA in 40 1/3 innings pitched -- all after he thought his playing days were over.
"The ER doctor said it was the worst hand incident that she's seen, and that's the third year that she's been there, so that didn't help," Slinkard said.
His family, his coach, Bryan Austin, and his teammate and best friend, Cameron Duke, were all by his side as he waited at the emergency room and prepared for surgery.
"Just knowing that they weren't going to give up on me and that they were going to have full faith in me, help me out with anything that I needed, it kept me up the whole time," Slinkard said.
Once the bandages came off, he realized a comeback was possible. The night before his first scheduled bullpen session, during which he would only throw fastballs because the scar tissue on his finger made it impossible for him to throw curveballs or changeups, he had a dream that he'd be back on the mound.
"It was like two dreams split," he said. "It was a nightmare of the accident that happened, and then it went blank. And then I had a dream that I was pitching. It was a big game or something. It was bases loaded. It was zero outs and I struck three guys out in a row. It woke me up, and it was kind of a wake-up call saying, 'Hey, I'm going to come back from this. God's got a plan, and it's going to work out for the best."
The way Slinkard, who will play college baseball at Lincoln College, sees it, his Semoball Awards nomination is a chance for him to step into the spotlight to thank God.
"Just oh my gosh, my hard work finally paid off," Slinkard said about his reaction to his finalist selection. "Not that it didn't pay off during the season, but now -- my whole family kept saying, 'God's got a plan the whole way, and he's going to make time for you to glorify him.' This is the time I'm going to give him back for allowing me to come back and play and everything that he did for me."
Morehead said he didn't think the selection would have meant much to him in the past, but now he understands what injured athletes go through and has even tried to reach out to others in his situation.
"When you actually go through an injury and go through something terrible like this, it just means something to you and you realize you've kind of got a little group, a little clan, especially the ACL," Morehead said. "Any time I see that scar, I'm just like, 'How far out of surgery are you?' [People tell me] 'Six months,' 'Eight months, 'Two years.'"
Morehead, an all-state lineman who has signed to play at Austin Peay, was about six months removed from his surgery when he returned to the track and field team.
"My track coach -- Coach [Tyson] Moyers -- he talked to me about it, and he said 'I'm in a tough position because of course we want you out here, but you have to do what's best for you having college football on the line,'" Morehead said. "I just told him, I said, 'Coach, you can tell me all you want, but I'm going to be ready.' ... My parents were a little bit worried about it, but I told them this is what I wanted to do -- I'm not going to have my senior year completely taken away. I was a little bit stubborn about it."
Morehead, who said he feels 100 percent healthy but only about 85 percent as strong as he was before the injury, never returned to the shot put distances he reached as a junior, but a seventh-place, all-state finish at the state meet gave him a happy ending to his high school career.
"That was just the main thing because last year I think I let the moment get to me, more so letting the moment own me instead of owning the moment," Morehead said. "I just got kind of caught up in the hype. You know, I made it to state, but then this past year was a business trip. I wasn't just going, I was finishing all-state."
Morehead, who was a Semoball Awards finalist in football last year, is also a finalist for this year's scholar-athlete award in addition to his comeback player nod.
"It's a nice little reward for people who put in the work because rehab is tough, and that's just the unsung part of it because if you put work in for sports, you can get recognition for that," Morehead said. "There's no one there at physical therapy. You don't get interviewed for that, so it's just nice to have some form of recognition for your hard work coming back because that's tough. Anyone can prepare for a sport. It's tough to come back from an injury."
The winners for player of the year in 19 sports, the best fans contest, the Semoball Cup and all other awards will be revealed on the night of the Semoball Awards, which are sponsored by First Midwest Bank and SEMO ESPN in addition to the Harry Blackwell Family of Dealerships, Athlon Sports and the St. Louis Cardinals. The night will include a red-carpet entrance, heavy hors d'oeuvres for dinner, an address from Finch and dessert from My Daddy's Cheesecake. Doors will open at 5:30 p.m. with the SEMO ESPN preshow beginning at 6 and the show following at 7.
General admission and VIP tickets, which include a meeting and photo opportunity with Finch, can be purchased at semoball.com/awards or by calling 573-388-2761.
"The whole night is going to be pretty cool just knowing all the players and what they've done, how hard they've worked," Slinkard said. "And the red carpet, that seems pretty cool, too."
---
Finalists for sports awards selected from 57 high schools in the semoball.com coverage are by a panel of sports editors and broadcasters. Finalists for Scholar-Atlete of the Year nominated by athletic directors. Schools without scholar-athlete finalists did not reply to requests.
Hunter Eftink, Notre Dame
Austin Hicks, Bell City
Michael Houchin, Jackson
Trever Lewis, East Carter County
Kameron Misner, Poplar Bluff
Trent Pobst, Scott City
Adam Pope, Notre Dame
Brandon Stuckenschneider, Poplar Bluff
Devin Trammell, Bernie
Chase Urhahn, Notre Dame
Delfincko Bogan, Charleston
Caleb Ellenburg, Bernie
Willie Jimerson, New Madrid County Central
Jeffery Porter, Scott County Central
Quinn Poythress, Notre Dame
Blake Reynolds, Jackson
Garret Reynolds, Woodland
Andre Statam, Central
Chris Stocks, Poplar Bluff
Fred Thatch, Sikeston
Johneisha Daniel, Scott County Central
Melanie McKuin, Dexter
Tyeshia Mitchell, Sikeston
Shelby Moon, Neelyville
Lexi Morris, Clearwater
Brianna Mueller, Saxony Lutheran
Heidi Shetley, Kennett
Shayna Tharp, Naylor
Cassidi Tomsu, Jackson
Raegan Wieser, Saxony Lutheran
Jackson Givens, Jackson
Jack Jeffers, Jackson
Levi Krauss, St. Vincent
Rudy McClellan, Notre Dame
Isaiah Williams, Poplar Bluff
Alaina Baumgart, Notre Dame
Chelsea Drum, Jackson
Carli Knott, Jackson
Jenny Morey, Van Buren
Tayler Winick, Jackson
Deandre Banks, Central
Steven Haley, Poplar Bluff
Bud Hilburn, Kennett
Preston Hobeck, Jackson
Noah Kronk, Dexter
Derrick Priggel, Portageville
Jalen Reddin, Central
Landon Strickland, Caruthersville
Josh Stone, Jackson
Nick Thompson, Malden
Omar Bailey, Malden
Xominique Davis, Jackson
Cortez Dobbins, Malden
Jaylen Flye-Sadler, Central
Peyton Montgomery, Central
Braion Owens, Central
Dremond Robinson, Malden
Dante Vandeven, Jackson
Edward Wilson, Kennett
Al Young, Central
Jonathan Bell, Notre Dame
Sarah Bell, Notre Dame
Kobe Franklin, Central
Gabe Wheeler, Sikeston
Brian Whitson, Advance
Valerie Bahr, Scott City
Alexis Dock, Kelly
Mallorie Maintz, Jackson
Maggie Shepherd, Sikeston
Summer Shockley, Van Buren
Taylor Tiffany, Portageville
Shayna Tharp, Naylor
Madeline Urhahn, Notre Dame
Logan Vaughan, Kennett
Riley Washburn, Neelyville
Eann Bergman, Perryville
Luke Dobbelare, Perryville
Benjamin Parsons, Notre Dame
Jose Reyes, Poplar Bluff
Luke Schlichting, Perryville
Torrie Helms, Sikeston
Grace Mirly, Saxony Lutheran
Brianna Mueller, Saxony Lutheran
Jordan Nelson, Jackson
Cassidi Tomsu, Jackson
Brogan Davis, Central
Jack Gard, Jackson
Sam Hahs, Central
Austin Hobbs, Jackson
Joey Janisse, Jackson
Cassidy Harris, Poplar Bluff
Morgan McAtee, Poplar Bluff
Taylor Norwood, Poplar Bluff
Caitlyn Palmer, Jackson
Josey Powell, Central
Brendan Boswell, Notre Dame
Ethan Flowers, Dexter
Noah Kronk, Dexter
Zain Siddiqui, Poplar Bluff
John Stroup, Notre Dame
Hadley Hilburn, Kennett
Carly Hopkins, Notre Dame
Josey Powell, Central
Kate Shetley, Kennett
MaKayla Waldner, Dexter
Denzell Britton, Poplar Bluff
Maurice Davis, Kelly
Earnest Fobbs, Sikeston
Bobby Jansen, Notre Dame
Dakota Maddox, Jackson
Jabreuna Brimlett, Poplar Bluff
Chelsea Drum, Jackson junior
Dakaria Johnson, Kelly
MaKayla Waldner, Dexter
Soley Webb, Poplar Bluff
Brooke Hogard, Perryville
Shyann Jines, Dexter
Jessica Lindsey, Dexter
Abbie McAlister, Notre Dame
Caitlin Petty, Leopold
Autumn Reid, Jackson
Alex Spears, Perryville
Kori Tapp, Poplar Bluff
Katie Verseman, St. Vincent
Lindsey Young, Bloomfield
Clayton Collier, Jackson
Matt King, Poplar Bluff
Carson McCord, Jackson
Jarrett Reisenbichler, Jackson
Ethan Stevens, Dexter
Jerry Fulton, Perryville boys soccer
Jeff Graviett, Notre Dame baseball and softball
Beth Lewis-Muse, Poplar Bluff swimming, track and field and cross country
Nathan Norman, Cape Central football
Frank Staple, Scott County Central boys basketball
Trevor Morehead, Chaffee football, basketball and track and field
Jarrett Reisenbichler, Jackson wrestling
Libbi Schnurbusch, Perryville volleyball
Tyler Slinkard, Jackson baseball
Nathan Watson, Twin Rivers basketball and baseball
BJ Carr, Kennett football, basketball, baseball and golf
Hannah Clark, Advance volleyball and softball
Thomas Himmelberg, Notre Dame soccer, basketball and baseball
Landon Johnson, Woodland basketball and baseball
Pablo Mattingly, Perryville boys soccer
Will Allen, Jackson
Tyler Battles, Bloomfield
Charles Brown, Kennett
Matt Campbell, Campbell
Haden Clark, Clearwater
Braden Cox, Scott City
Caleb Ellenburg, Bernie
Caleb Friedrich, Eagle Ridge
Luke Harris, Charleston
Quinton Herkenhoff, Bell City
Tristan Hollis, Van Buren
Evan Hovis, Marquand
Dalton Huffman, Kelly
Contrell Johnson, South Pemiscot
Zak Johnson, Oran
Drake Kesler, Scott County Central
Trever Lewis, East Carter County
Trevor Morehead, Chaffee
Drew Palmer, New Madrid County Central
Tyler Pech, Notre Dame
Sam Phillips, Neelyville
Corey Pratt, Puxico
Garret Reynolds, Woodland
Jacob Seabaugh, Oak Ridge
Brandon Stuckenschneider, Poplar Bluff
Josh Vogel, Saxony Lutheran
Luke Williams, Sikeston
Grant Woodfin, Advance
Madison Avance, Scott County Central
Elizabeth Blanton, Sikeston
Bella Bowers, Scott City
Hannah Clark, Advance
Emma Cook, Meadow Heights
Marissa Crawford, Charleston
Samantha Cryts, Puxico
Allie Cummins, Oran
Kattie Davis, South Pemiscot
Chelsea Delay, Bloomfield
Alexa Garner, New Madrid County Central
Cassidy Harris, Poplar Bluff
Jamie Hodge, Delta
Allie Holmes, Clearwater
McKayla Hunt, Bell City
Emily Jackson, Eagle Ridge
Olivia Jansen, Notre Dame
Sarah Kitchen, Central
Ashley Law, Neelyville
Kaitlin McFerron, Chaffee
Alyssa Myers, Marquand
Taylor Osborn, Campbell
Samantha Ratledge, Kelly
Lauren Rich, Naylor
Kate Shetley, Kennett
Sabrena Shipley, Jackson
Chelsa Seyer, Oak Ridge
Carly Stucker, East Carter County
Daria Thompson, Perryville
Audrey Wilkinson, Woodland
Kayla Winkler, St. Vincent
Connect with the Southeast Missourian Newsroom:
For corrections to this story or other insights for the editor, click here. To submit a letter to the editor, click here. To learn about the Southeast Missourian’s AI Policy, click here.