Article misleading on tobacco tax issue

By Brad Ketcher

I am writing in response to an article that appeared in this week's Southeast Missourian, "Two gas stations close." Missouri is facing a very challenging economic time. And, it is unfortunate that the convenience store industry, along with many businesses across the state, are feeling the impact. However, I take strong exception to the argument that Proposition A plays a role here.

What your story failed to point out is that, today, Missouri's excise tax on a pack of cigarettes is one of the lowest in the nation. Only seven states are lower. Even with the increase proposed in Proposition A, Missouri would rank toward the middle of all states. And, importantly, the tax on a pack of cigarettes in Illinois and Kansas will still be higher. Therefore, the argument that consumers would be encouraged to cross the border and purchase cigarettes in Illinois just doesn't hold any water.

In addition, yes, one of the goals of Proposition A is to reduce the staggeringly high rate of smoking in Missouri. However, history shows that even with a higher excise tax, many adult smokers will continue to smoke. Where we will make our greatest difference is in keeping our kids from taking up the tobacco habit, in the first place. And, unless these convenience store operators are selling to minors, that shouldn't have a noticeable bearing on their bottom line.

If we want to talk economics, let's talk about the economic hit that tobacco brings to bear on every single Missouri taxpayer. If you consider the direct health-care costs and productivity loss attributed to tobacco use in Missouri, each of us is hit with a whopping $700 each and every year. Don't just take my word for it. Go to the Missouri Department of Health's Web site (www.dhss.state.mo.us) and see for yourself.

Proposition A is about leveling the playing field and asking Big Tobacco to pay its fair share. That is why Missouri voters should say "Yes" to Proposition A on November 5.

Brad Ketcher is with the coalition Citizens for a Healthy Missouri.